Bagatelle

Bagatelle sits at 115 Duval Street in a beautifully restored Victorian house that ranks among Key West's most charming dining settings. The open-air verandas and lush tropical gardens create an atmosphere that feels both romantic and genuinely Keys-authentic. The kitchen leans into fresh local seafood and Caribbean-inflected preparations, suited to guests who want a polished meal without losing that island informality. Bagatelle is the kind of place that lingers in memory long after you've left Key West — an experience worth planning your evening around.