Roostica Pizzeria

Roostica Pizzeria on MacDonald Avenue serves up wood-fired pies in a neighborhood setting that feels refreshingly removed from the Duval Street tourist corridor. It's a residential-area pizzeria where Key West locals actually go when they want a good pie without the crowds or the markup. The wood-fired approach brings a crackly, slightly charred crust that sets it apart from the typical slice joint. Whether you're staying nearby or just want to eat like a local, Roostica is worth seeking out.