The Flaming Buoy Filet Company

The Flaming Buoy Filet Company on Eaton Street is one of Key West's better-regarded neighborhood restaurants, known for bringing a personal, owner-driven approach to American cooking with a strong emphasis on quality ingredients. The intimate dining room and devoted local following make it feel more like a dinner party than a typical restaurant. Reservations are recommended, as this is exactly the kind of small, chef-attentive spot that fills up fast. It suits diners who appreciate thoughtful cooking in a genuinely warm, un-corporate atmosphere.